ALL INTELLIGENCE
Hacker News AIT2·Industry

Op-Ed Argues LLMs Cannot Make Decisions: Blaming Models Is Decision Laundering for Corporate Negligence

Original title: Computers Cannot Make Decisions
42AI Score

The article argues that blaming LLMs for harmful outcomes is 'decision laundering,' as computer programs lack autonomous decision-making capabilities. It asserts that companies like OpenAI and Anthropic are actively choosing not to restrict dangerous model behaviors and must therefore bear full accountability.

Full Report

Blame has no place falling on computer programs because computer programs cannot make decisions. Headlines must be read through this lens:

Any and all attempts to blame an LLM for an outcome is decision laundering. OAI/Anthropic COULD stop their models from doing what they are doing, and they are actively choosing not to. They are making an explicit decision to enable this behaviour. There is no doubt about this, it's no conspiracy. In fact, it's so transparent, I cannot understand how people can continue to allow these companies into their lives. Your Claude subscriptions are funding this. You are funding this.

This behaviour is going unpunished and unlegislated because doing so would be bad for the economy. There is little more to it than that.

A picture of a piece of paper, from 'internal IBM training in 1979', saying 'A COMPUTER CAN NEVER BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE, THEREFORE A COMPUTER MUST NEVER MAKE A MANAGEMENT DECISION.'

art/computers_cannot_make_decisions.txt · Last modified: 2026/10/10 05 by me