ALL INTELLIGENCE
Hacker News AIT2·Open Source

QGIS Bans AI-Assisted Contributions to Enforce Human Review and Policy Compliance

Original title: QGIS bans AI assisted contributions
42AI Score

The QGIS project has officially banned AI-assisted code contributions via its Enhancement Proposal (QEP) process to ensure traceability and quality. The policy mandates strict human review for all Pull Requests, preventing unverified automated content from entering the core codebase. This move highlights a broader trend in open-source communities shifting from technical acceptance of LLMs to governance-focused regulation.

Full Report

Contents5 sections

QEPs (QGIS Enhancement Proposals) are used in the process of creating and discussing new enhancements or policy for QGIS

QEPs should generally be created for (only examples):

  • Large application wide changes (e.g major UI redesign)
  • Large work with wider scope (e.g something that might effect how layers are loaded)
  • Community processes and policies (e.g 3.0 release, changes to coding conventions)

Generally smaller features do not require a QEP unless they can have large knock on effect.

QEPs which describe project policies (such as those which describe coding conventions, acceptable practice for Pull Request reviews, etc) are mutable, and can be revised in future. See Processes and Policies section below for a description on how to amend an existing QEP.

Process and policies

If you are:

  • Proposing a brand new QEP: make a copy of the QEP-0-Template.md file, populate the template and rename as required. Submit a Pull Request to this repository adding your new QEP file.
  • Proposing a change to an existing QEP: just submit a Pull Request which modifies the corresponding QEP markdown file accordingly.

The same policies apply whether you a proposing a new QEP or a change to an existing QEP:

  • The proposal must be open for at least two weeks. This may be extended upon request (eg, "I'm on holidays but have feedback to give").
  • Proposals (both for new QEPs and amendments to existing QEPs) should be announced to the community via a message to the QGIS Developer Mailing List. The QGIS User Mailing List should also be messaged if the changes impact on QGIS end-users.
  • Comments from the whole community are invited and valuable! You do not need any special permissions or status in order to give feedback. We welcome feedback from all parties, whether you're a developer, a documenter, a translator or an end-user.
  • For acceptance, a proposal requires at least 2 +1's from core QGIS developers or PSC members
  • If -1 votes are received from core QGIS developers, then the proposal should be amended or further discussion conducted to satisfy all interested parties. If consensus cannot be reached, the proposal can be raised to the PSC for voting.
  • A PR can also be opened at the same time - this is done at the developer's own risk as the proposal may be rejected and the development effort wasted

When the discussion and voting period ends, one of the following actions are taken:

  • If the proposal was accepted: the Pull Request should be amended, making sure that the QEP markdown file correctly reflects the final accepted form of the proposal. It should then be merged. Please announce to QGIS Developer Mailing List the outcome of the proposal.
  • If the proposal was rejected: the Pull Request should be closed

List of approved QEPs

  • #314 Code style and practice guidelines. This QEP documents coding standards and conventions used throughout the QGIS code base. Developers are required to follow these standards when submitting code to QGIS.
  • #323 Change submission and merge policies. This QEP documents policies for submission of changes to the main QGIS code repository. Developers are required to follow these standards when submitting code to QGIS.
  • #320 Backport policies. This QEP documents the standards and requirements for backporting changes from the master branch to Long Term Release (LTR) and current stable release branches in QGIS. Developers must follow these guidelines when submitting backports.
  • #408 AI tool use policy. This QEP documents the QGIS project policy regarding the use of AI/LLM tools by contributors.
  • #425 Stable API and document format policy. This QEP documents the QGIS project policy regarding API stability and document format stability.

FAQ

Do I need a QEP for a bug fix?

Nope. Just open a PR