HOT RADAR
research_paperHEAT 8.0°

AI CURATED HOT STORY · 11/18/2026

AI-Written Referee Reports Threaten Peer Review, Economists Warn

1 reports archived1 independent sourcesupdated 11/18/2026, 21:51:03
Synthesis & Latest Updates
1 Sources Cross-Validated

Economists from the Federal Reserve Board, University of Pennsylvania, CEPR and NBER warn that large language models can now write papers and referee reports, putting peer review at risk of collapse without new norms. Their experiment shows AI detectors flag reports written by AI but not those merely proofread or edited by it, and they argue AI-generated referee reports should be treated like plagiarism and rejected.

LATEST/Economists from the Federal Reserve Board, University of Pennsylvania, CEPR and NBER warn that large language models can now write papers and referee reports, putting peer review at risk of collapse without new norms. Their experiment shows AI detectors flag reports written by AI but not those merely proofread or edited by it, and they argue AI-generated referee reports should be treated like plagiarism and rejected.

Hourly heat curve

27 fully observed hours
Now
8.0
Peak
14.623:00
24h change
-42%

The line compares only sources observed throughout; gap hours are interpolated to keep the trend continuous.

Coverage timeline

Total 1 reports · Latest first
  1. Hacker News AIT2·78 pts
    • AI detectors distinguish AI-written referee reports from merely AI-edited ones, offering journals a practical tool
    • Authors argue AI-generated reports amount to plagiarism and should trigger close reading and rejection at the first error
    • Individual restraint has proven insufficient, requiring collective professional norms to solve the collective action problem